Commentary. Reviews. Rants. Television. Pop culture. Whatever. It do what it do.
From the creator of Jammer's Reviews

Caprica review: ‘Ghosts in the Machine’

Caprica: Ghosts in the Machine

Daniel embarks on a psychological war of wills to coerce the U-87 into revealing that it contains Zoe’s memories. Joseph finds his mettle tested as he searches for Tamara in New Cap City.

Air date: 3/19/2010
Written by Michael Taylor
Directed by Wayne Rose

****

Note: This review contains significant spoilers.


At last, here’s the story (or its first chapter, at least) that was inevitable from the moment Zoe ended up in the robot by her father’s doing. If “Ghosts in the Machine” proves anything, it’s that Caprica is at its best when it is intimate and personal. The series’ most engrossing moments of drama and suspense to date come not because lives hang in the balance or because of complicated plots, but because the story deals strictly with its characters — and because the stakes are so clear and, potentially, so personally and emotionally devastating.

Daniel is now convinced that Zoe’s consciousness has survived in the U-87, but Zoe has no intention of admitting that to him. When Daniel talks to the U-87 as Zoe, it ignores him. It will only acknowledge him as the U-87. But Daniel so desperately needs proof from the U-87 that Zoe is still in there, so he launches a psychological battle to wear her down. Can he force her to show her hand?

This, more than any Caprica outing to date, builds great scenes out of character psychology and emotional manipulation. For that, you need actors who can deliver. They do. Eric Stoltz portrays a man whom I felt a great deal of empathy for while at the same time being put off by his harsh, strong-armed tactics and determination that at times approaches Zoe’s obstinacy as a challenge. And yet his desperation is palpable. He just wants to talk to his little girl again. And to do that, he will put Zoe through one emotional manipulation after another.

Consider the scene where he has her constantly reloading the machinegun while talking about the fire that burned down the old house when Zoe was five years old. This is a great piece of cinematic storytelling, where all parts — acting, directing, editing, dialogue — come together to create something that’s sort of mesmerizing while also generating unexpected suspense: Will Daniel get the confirmation he seeks? And will Zoe give it to him, willingly or otherwise? The robot hesitates at one moment, and Daniel thinks he sees a very Zoe-specific emotional response — but does he? He can’t be certain. Good stuff.

Alessandra Toressani is very effective in these scenes without saying a single word. She sells Zoe’s emotions every step of the way: terror, anger, frustration, sadness. You watch these scenes, and it becomes unthinkable that this series could’ve been made had it not established the narrative device of switching back and forth between the robot and the girl. Because Toressani’s reaction shots provide for us — but not the other characters — a running monologue for the robot’s feelings, we are constantly reminded of the disconnect between how we perceive the Cylon and how everyone else does. For everyone else, it is a piece of hardware. Maybe not Daniel. Not anymore. He wants to be convinced otherwise.

This sets the stage for some brilliant scenes. Such as: Daniel, RoboZoe, and the Ring of Fire. Great stuff. Daniel lashes out at Zoe for her fear of growing up, so much that she went out and blew up a train. How much do you think Zoe might want to tell him that it wasn’t her who blew up the train? Probably a lot, but she wants to keep her identity secret even more. (*) And then Daniel sets a ring of gasoline around the U-87 ablaze, because he knows Zoe is afraid of fire. The U-87 does not budge. This is a duel of endurance, wonderfully acted.

* As pointed out in the comments, RoboZoe could not have known that Real Life Zoe didn’t blow up the maglev, since RoboZoe’s memories are based on a version of Real Zoe that she uploaded presumably several hours or days before the bombing. Unless, of course, the alleged Apotheosis miracle that allowed Virtual Zoe to become alive inside the Cylon (and hinted at by Virtual Zoe being covered in blood in the pilot) somehow also allowed memory transfer at the time of the explosion. But I doubt that’s what occurred or what the writers intended.

And then, of course, there’s Daniel, RoboZoe, the Gun and the Dog, which takes the standoff to an escalation that seems to approach madness. He offers Zoe the ultimate binary choice: He orders the U-87, on the count of five, to shoot his beloved dog. Only Zoe has the power to intervene and stop it. Will she? Or will the dog be killed? (Surely these writers wouldn’t kill a cute and innocent dog?! It’s television anathema!) It must be said that this is a blatantly manipulative scene, which cuts to the dog as Daniel gets to “four” and as the camera snap-zooms in. It also must be said that this is an absolutely brilliant scene, shot and edited and acted and directed for maximum effect. And the show by this point has earned it as its payoff. The manipulation arises completely from Daniel’s own desperate motivation.

And I also liked how the binary choice ultimately became more complex, involving the blanks in the gun, and what Zoe knew and when she knew it. But clearly Zoe is reaching a point where she may not be able to sit idly much longer. “Get me out of here before I do something I regret,” she tells Lacy, somewhat chillingly. A somewhat unspoken theme is the question of just how much Zoe is in control of the U-87, and how much of it controls her. The “trinity” concept floated earlier in the season is worth revisiting, because as much as it seems Zoe controls the Cylon, it’s also clear that it has its own influence on her.

This theme runs parallel with Joseph’s story, where he continues his search for his daughter. He finds that the longer he stays in the game, the more profound its impact may be on him. Emmanuelle warns him that people lose themselves and change because of the game, and I believe that. The affect something has on your life is in large part controlled by your own personal investment in it. If you convince yourself something matters, then it can matter, even if it’s not real. I think that’s where both Joseph and Daniel are in trying to find their virtual daughters. Because, let’s face it, their daughters are dead, and they both know it.

Initially Joseph can’t bring himself to kill anyone, even in VR (which strikes me as a bit of a stretch). He asks Sam at one point how one brings oneself to commit murder. Sam tells him to think of it as not real — as a game — which is perhaps a little too self-awarely ironic under the circumstances, but fair enough. New Cap City felt much more alive and urgent this week, and I continue to enjoy the club atmosphere, the period detail, and the look and design of the city itself, which as a whole evokes Dark City.

Joseph finds himself lowering himself to the standards of the game in his investigation of people who have seen Tamara. He takes virtual drugs that allow him to play harder and faster (and that have real-life addictive risks). At one point he wipes out half a room full of people because he Means Business.

I wonder how long it will be before Joseph finds Tamara, and if he will even recognize her by then — or if she will become a lost spirit doomed to forever haunt V-World. The last shot of New Cap City is a foreboding one; it takes the sweet image of Tamara’s T-flower drawing and repeats it, larger and larger, turning it into something menacing and alien. I suspect Tamara herself will be similarly menacing and alien by the time we catch up with her.

It’s probably no coincidence that the best episodes of Caprica seem to happen when the show subtracts elements rather than adding them. I don’t need four plotlines every week. The A/B structure here (with a few other brief scenes thrown in) allows us to focus, rather than having our attention splintered between an A/B/C/D structure. Less is more. Truth is, I probably could’ve watched an entire episode that was just Daniel and Zoe facing off in various scenarios of escalating psychological warfare. But what we had was plenty enough, and quite excellent.

Now to fire off some bullets (but none at dogs):

• The episode shoehorns in a scene where Vergis shows up and tells Amanda that Daniel had the MCP stolen and killed his friends. This scene works (despite being divorced from the rest of the story) because it shows the calculated, long-term strategy of destruction by Vergis, and because the performances are so good. Look at how much sincerity and emotion there is in Vergis’ eyes when he tells Amanda this news.

• The drag-queen’s riddle certainly had some cerebral, captial-s thematic Significance to it, no?

• You may perhaps never look at a BSG Cylon Centurion quite the same way after Caprica.

• Doesn’t Joseph have a job he has to either go to or get fired from? Is he on vacation or something? Maybe it’s the weekend.

• What is Emmanuelle’s incentive for helping Joseph? She keeps insisting she’s going to be paid, but there’s clearly someone else pulling strings here.

• Amanda still sees her dead brother in hallucinations. She goes to the site of the car accident and talks on the phone with Clarice. This didn’t take up much time, and the scenes were fine, but honestly, I just don’t care.


21 Comments
  1. Brad - Friday, March 26, 2010 - 8:43 pm

    I find Caprica intriguing, but it hasn’t quite taken off for me. I feel that it could do so at any moment, though. I look forward to tonight’s episode.

    However, one thing about Ghost in the Machine did stick out at me: doesn’t Daniel have cameras in his laboratory? If not, couldn’t he put some there? That seems like a simpler way of confirming Zoe’s habitation in the robot. However, it would be less interesting. Also, it wouldn’t satisfy Daniel’s desire to outwit and overpower Zoe. Is he jealous that his daughter achieved something greater that he did (the Avatar)?

    Re: Joseph’s not being at work: I think that was raised in a recent episode, wasn’t it? His assistant calls and asks where he is, I recall. I assume that his work is giving him some amount of slack, given what’s happened. I’m glad that it isn’t a subplot, since Caprica has more than enough balls in the air already (and still adds more, anyway)!

  2. Timothy - Saturday, March 27, 2010 - 4:03 am

    “How much do you think Zoe might want to tell him that it wasn’t her who blew up the train?” This isn’t possible because it’s not really Zoe that’s in the U-87 but Zoe’s avatar and the avatar doesn’t know if Zoe was or wasn’t responsible for the bombing.

  3. Josh - Saturday, March 27, 2010 - 7:27 am

    Yes, this was a really good episode. But it still retains that Caprica issue where it feels like it is building to something, but that something is always for later. The series is still plodding. But at least this time, an individual episode had something really good about it.

  4. knitpicker - Saturday, March 27, 2010 - 9:49 am

    Yay Jammer!

    Funnily enough, I felt that both the story lines were overplayed and repetitive.

    How come Philmon can tell that roboZoe is more than a robot, but Daniel can’t? There was the small reveal during the ring of fire as there was during the gun reloading sequence. This may not be the intent, but it feels to me like Daniel doesn’t want to accept his gut instinct, that he is using it as an excuse to punish roboZoe by breaking her emotionally.

    For me, Joe Adama stumbling around Cap city was too much of a reprise of Tamara doing the same thing. Since Tamara asked Heracles to find her dad, why is it so difficult for him to do so? How does Heracles have the means to “hire” someone to help Joe?

    Favorite vignets:
    Sam’s response when Joe asks him how to kill someone. Sam is such a well drawn character – I actually feel like he is more fleshed out than Joe, despite the very limited amount that we see him.
    Amanda’s response to Virgis followed by her reaction to the information.

    Alessandra Toressani is showing some serious acting chops! I agree that they are using the robo vs cyber Zoe very effectively.

    Technology rants
    Daniel Greystone, computer genius and corporate dirty fighter, doesn’t have effective protective software on his home computer (previous episode)? I’m with Brad – he doesn’t have a surveillance camera on the cylon that his entire future is riding on?

  5. Andy - Sunday, March 28, 2010 - 1:44 am

    While there are things about Caprica that I like, I, too, feel like the show is all about hovering rather than moving. It’s hard for me to care about a lot of it. This episode did manage to focus on some of the parts of the show that do interest me.

    That said, I have always found the shots of Zoe-as-U-87 to be distracting and unnecessary. I know they want to save on CGI costs and actually use the actor they’re paying, but every time it shows Ms. Torressani instead of the robot I find myself wondering “what does this *actually* look like? Does U-87 always stand with its arms on its hips? Does it fidget as much as Zoe?” Ultimately, it makes it harder for me to remember that this looks like an essentially inanimate object to everyone in the show, rather than easier.

    -Andy

  6. alex99a - Sunday, March 28, 2010 - 1:15 pm

    So the alternative is, we see the U87 standing there, immobile except for perhaps the eye scanning back and forth, while Daniel natters away about whatever. Absolutely nothing to convey any reaction or emotion from the Zoe avatar, because if the robot reacted it would be the payoff Daniel is trying to provoke. This isn’t about saving money on CGI, this is a brilliant dodge to keep the human alive in our minds along with the robot. Sorry you don’t like it, but I certainly do.

  7. AnthonyE1778 - Sunday, March 28, 2010 - 7:15 pm

    I thought this was a very good episode of Caprica. I wouldn’t quite give it top marks, but then again the show itself has been quite frustrating for me. I completely agree with you, Jammer, about the A/B/C/D storyline problem. This show is at its best when focusing only on one or two of those per episode. The ‘Ring of Fire’ scene was a definite highlight.

    However, Torresani is quite a good actress, but not great. Her delivery of certain lines just doesn’t click with me sometimes. However, being as how this is a SyFy show, I am glad that they did choose an actress with some chops.

    Overall, even with this very good episode, the show is not yet up to scratch in comparison to the great BSG. I still watch it because I still have very high hopes for the series. I do hope that SyFy does not cancel the series.

  8. Mal - Sunday, March 28, 2010 - 11:39 pm

    If you grew up reading Asimov’s Robot Series (and I did), the psychological testing of the Robot made for one of the best episodes of science fiction possible!

  9. knitpicker - Monday, March 29, 2010 - 2:27 pm

    Ad absurdum
    The impression that I got from the podcasts was that most of the BSG plotting seemed to be very much in the moment. It would not surprise me if if RDM and Co never considereda direct connection between skin jobs and Caprica characters. Of course, that won’t stop me from speculating wildly. So, if Daniel Greystone is “Daniel,” wouldn’t it be deliciously ironic if Virgis became Cavil. Talk about the ultimate triumph. In fact, the two skin job factions could be made up of Capricans on one side and Taurons on the other.

  10. enniofan - Tuesday, March 30, 2010 - 9:07 am

    What if Serge gets downloaded somewhere along the line and is actually the original hybrid seen in Razor? lol

    I’m wondering if the GDD storyline has been dropped entirely. Seemed to be such a large part of the first few episodes.. I can’t remember which episode, maybe “Gravedancing,” where Durham says “I lost everyone on that train,” and it seems that’s the last of them outside of a mention or 2. I was expecting some kind of payoff/ interaction between Clarice and Duram regarding this — what seems to me — interesting line of dialogue.

  11. Jammer - Wednesday, March 31, 2010 - 9:48 pm

    Timothy caught me in a logical gaffe when bringing up the good point about the maglev bombing. I’ve amended the review.

  12. Evan - Thursday, April 1, 2010 - 9:38 am

    I usually agree with you, but I just can’t here. There just isn’t much of a plot to the show so far. The V world game is slow, preposterous, and incredibly boring(with a terrible lack of payoff in the last episode).

  13. enniofan - Thursday, April 1, 2010 - 9:58 am

    “The V world game is slow, preposterous, and incredibly boring”

    but I think the point of the V-world and New Cap City isn’t for them to be playing the game for the sake of the show.
    The fact that it exists and is seen by the STO (or at least Clarice) as a kind of afterlife where people can live forever is the point, and why Sister Clarice has been after the Zoe avatar.

    They say it themselves in earlier episodes: no one knows the point of the V-world NCC game — it’s a hack and is just there.

  14. Evan - Monday, April 5, 2010 - 9:17 am

    I meant that the parts of the show that take place in the V world game of New Cap is slow, preposterous, and incredibly boring.

  15. karatasiospa - Sunday, April 18, 2010 - 4:49 am

    jammer what happened with the review of :end of the line”?

  16. Jammer - Tuesday, April 20, 2010 - 8:13 pm

    I got busy with some personal business and had to step away from the reviewing table for a week or two, and then I forgot what I wanted to say about the episode, so I’m going to go back and watch the show again this week and should have it posted probably late this week.

  17. Hey - Saturday, April 24, 2010 - 6:10 pm

    Where is the review for that last episode of Caprica?

  18. Jammer - Saturday, April 24, 2010 - 6:53 pm

    It will be posted. Soon. I promise. I was working on it yesterday, but only had a few free minutes and then had to go out of town.

  19. Nolan - Tuesday, May 3, 2011 - 2:59 am

    Hey, Jammer, I just read your Review for Battlestar Galactica Season Two Valley of Darkness. You totally called an event in this episode, way back then. even if your estimate was a bit off. I remembered and had to look and see if I was right. =p That really is too funny.

  20. Peremensoe - Monday, January 7, 2013 - 12:25 am

    The Zoe-avatar may not have the actual memory of not-detonating the bomb, but that doesn’t at all preclude her from knowing that the Zoe-original had no such plan or capacity–that Zoe-original in fact would have been (was) horrified at the imminent prospect.

  21. J - Friday, July 19, 2013 - 6:15 pm

    In the next episode, End of Line, virtual Zoe has a flashback and in that flashback is a memory of real Zoe sending the last message to her mom. So unless this is a momentary lapse of continuity, it does show that virtual Zoe has memories of the events after the last time real Zoe put a holoband on, at least up to the point where she sent her mom that message.

Submit a comment